Related by context. All words. (Click for frequent words.) 78 plaintiff 78 Plaintiffs 72 plantiffs 66 Plaintiffs attorneys 65 defendants 63 plantiff 63 lawsuit 61 lawsuits 60 Defendants 60 Korein Tillery 59 monetary damages 59 Plaintiff 58 Appellants 58 relators 58 Poligrip contains 58 attorneys 58 appellants 58 Jeanie Rizzo 58 Kevin Knestrick 58 Mike Vrabel Ben Leber 58 attorney Dennis Gingold 57 attorney Clement Donelon 57 nonparties 57 Shawn Khorrami 57 multidistrict litigation MDL 57 Wolf Popper 57 litigants 56 plaintiffs appellants 56 punitive damages 56 Edelson McGuire LLC 56 classaction 56 attorney Carmen Durso 56 tort claimants 55 injunctive relief 55 punitives 55 Venus Soltan 55 Title VII retaliation 55 declaratory relief 55 News.com Dawn Kawamoto 55 compensatory damages 55 Rebecca Randles 54 attorney Brian Kabateck 54 tort 54 seeming ordinariness 54 p laintiff 54 cocounsel 54 qui tam actions 54 KamberEdelson LLC 54 summary judgment dismissing 54 summary judgment motions 54 counterclaims asserted 53 appellees 53 Provost Umphrey 53 negligent entrustment 53 tortfeasors 53 wrongful death 53 Piacentile 53 Jeannie Rizzo 53 lawyer Jere Beasley 53 claimants 53 Concepcions 53 litigation 53 multidistrict 53 plaintiffs allege 53 qui tam whistleblower 53 Aaron Freiwald 53 arrhythmia cardiology 53 petitioners 53 summary judgment 53 Edelson McGuire 52 multidistrict litigation 52 defendants appellees 52 Tanys Lancaster Jill Patricot 52 tortious conduct 52 interpleader 52 Lakins 52 compensatory damages punitive damages 52 equitable estoppel 52 damages 52 seeks compensatory damages 52 defendant 52 Theodore Boutrous Jr. 52 Avenatti 52 Marshall Tanick 52 Buzbee Law Firm 52 anti SLAPP motions 51 asbestos claimants 51 anti SLAPP motion 51 qui tam lawsuit 51 Liaison Counsel 51 Rooker Feldman doctrine 51 Rochon Genova LLP 51 Sherrie R. Savett 51 BrownGreer 51 Ted Boutrous member 51 attorney Daniel Becnel 51 Amanda Obney 51 Jerome Schlichter 51 Plantiffs 51 Janet Loures 51 Hausfeld LLP 51 Tony Buzbee 51 Ken Roosa 51 reorganized Parmalat 51 CAFA jurisdiction 51 Seeger Weiss LLP 51 Engle progeny 51 partial summary judgment 51 SLAPP motion 51 Quiznos franchisees 51 Cornelius Nestler lawyer 51 Schottel Jr. 51 Tammy Kitzmiller 51 qui tam 51 FEHA 51 posttrial motions 51 lawyers 51 Ohlemeyer 51 Chris Lodewyks 50 LakinChapman 50 EarthJustice representing 50 Ecuadorean plaintiffs 50 Cohen Milstein 50 Reed Kathrein 50 Lisoni 50 Philip Sieff 50 Stephen Tillery 50 Marc Wolinsky 50 FINRA arbitration 50 Baine Kerr 50 Relators 50 Judge Selna 50 Rosenblatts 50 putative class 50 Foresight Unlimited Signature 50 Kevin Van Wart 50 promissory estoppel 50 seeks declaratory 50 proximate causation 50 Jeremy Alters 50 counterclaim 50 affirmative defenses 50 granted summary judgment 50 declaratory judgment 50 postconviction proceedings 50 suit 50 Appellees 50 lawsuits alleging 50 Judge Ronald Silkworth 50 Seeger Weiss 50 son Arlam 50 Lakin Law Firm 50 Hanford downwinders 50 Philip Morris RJ Reynolds 50 Philip Bialowitz 50 WCAB 50 cy pres 50 P laintiffs 50 compulsory counterclaim 50 Jay Edelson 50 summary judgment motion 50 prejudgment interest 49 Eleventh Circuit affirmed 49 qui tam relator 49 Timothy Kosnoff 49 interlocutory appeal 49 MegaClaims litigation 49 Plaintiffs Steering Committee 49 attorney Steven Donziger 49 Cabraser 49 Scherker 49 Movants 49 Kellner LLP 49 attorney Mikal Watts 49 Righthaven lawsuits 49 Rigsby sisters 49 colorable claim 49 Kardis 49 Plaintiffs contend 49 p laintiffs 49 replead 49 Sabraw 49 litigant 49 interrogatory responses 49 litigating 49 Bernstein Litowitz 49 Alan Himmelfarb 49 Irukera 49 filed amicus briefs 49 Kenneth Ruffo 49 Frank Schwaller 49 nonsuit 49 postjudgment interest 49 Alan Fuchsberg 49 granting summary judgment 49 Bieder 49 attorney Stephen Yagman 49 en banc rehearing 49 MegaClaims 49 fraudulent concealment 49 settlement 49 Wrongful Death Act 49 RJ Reynolds Philip Morris 49 attorney Mitchell Garabedian 49 Ninth Circuit 49 precluded summary judgment 49 dispositive motions 49 qui tam plaintiffs 49 injunctive action 49 Wrongful termination 49 Chanins 49 Norgle 49 Alan H. Perer 49 judicially estopped 48 negligent misrepresentation 48 Michael Piuze 48 claimant 48 Intervenors 48 liberally construe 48 Declaratory Judgment 48 Judge Lifland 48 Federal Tort Claims 48 appellate court 48 First Amended Complaint 48 factually distinguishable 48 Bowoto 48 unspecified compensatory 48 Cynthia Cappel Coffey 48 JNOV motion 48 mootness 48 Tim Kosnoff 48 Qui tam 48 SOX whistleblower 48 Rothken 48 additur 48 Pigford v. Glickman 48 compel arbitration 48 Dyller 48 Vianale 48 subrogee 48 Sandra Stier 48 Tikellis 48 CEO Christine LaSala 48 Hollis Haltom 48 litigate 48 & Rudoff LLP 48 defendents 48 Gwire 48 Michael Delikat 48 Susman Godfrey 48 unlawful detainer 48 Second Amended Complaint 48 injunctive 48 William S. Ohlemeyer 48 Sucharow 48 XPRT Ventures 48 patently frivolous 48 Dan Kotin 48 Liss Riordan 48 appellate judges 48 appellee 48 Spencer Hosie 48 nonfrivolous 48 Delaware Chancery 48 classaction lawsuit 48 retaliatory discharge 48 Eleventh Circuit 48 Dolores Troiani 48 JNOV 48 attorney Jon Loevy 48 anti SLAPP statute 48 Phillip Wittmann 48 intervenors 48 Attorneys 48 attorney 48 Laurian Miller 48 attorney Stan Chesley 48 sued 48 quo warranto 48 amici 48 attorney Patrick Noaker 48 Weisses misrepresented 48 quantum meruit 48 preclusive effect 48 Slesingers 47 ConnectU founders Cameron Winklevoss 47 Lester Brickman 47 Individual Defendants 47 fraudulent inducement 47 lawyer Pablo Fajardo 47 Selna 47 demurrers 47 filed counterclaim 47 Judge Hellerstein 47 DFEH 47 Kinderstart 47 Judge Alvin Hellerstein 47 mass tort 47 Kabateck Brown 47 Lerach Coughlin Stoia 47 Lago Agrio litigation 47 Justice Maurice Cullity 47 Appellants argue 47 justices 47 Harish Bharti 47 Finra arbitration 47 defendant appellee 47 inverse condemnation 47 substantively unconscionable 47 Howard Godnick 47 malicious prosecution 47 Aftab Ahmed Bajwa 47 justiciable controversy 47 equitable subrogation 47 Cobell v. Norton 47 compulsory counterclaims 47 laches 47 intervenor status 47 Torture Victim Protection 47 prima facie tort 47 Lac Vieux 47 Rothken Law Firm 47 Jim Schwebel 47 Dram Shop Act 47 Lieff Cabraser Heimann 47 attorney Olivier Taillieu 47 CAFC affirmed 47 Plaintiffs Appellants 47 Verified Complaint 47 Judge LT Senter 47 seeks injunctive relief 47 seeks declaratory judgment 47 granted certiorari 47 qui tam relators 47 Declaratory Judgment Act 47 postconviction motion 47 Wolf Popper LLP 47 Settling Defendants 47 Texas RioGrande Legal Aid 47 Napoli Bern 47 Judge Garaufis 47 Kodrins 47 Tevrizian 47 Litigants 47 unliquidated damages 47 Wilsons Kilbert 47 Lieff Cabraser 47 litigated 47 Guy Schall 47 qui tam lawsuits 47 complainants 47 declaratory judgments 47 multimillion dollar verdicts 47 Baum Hedlund 47 claim preclusion 47 tapes Trentadue 47 Fred Isquith 47 Sauby 47 reargument 47 Unfair Competition Law 47 Crouppen 47 amicus briefs 47 Punitive damages 47 Judge Stanwood Duval 47 Savett 47 Marilyn Maneely 47 attorney Jere Beasley 47 intentional torts 47 dram shop 47 Nichols Kaster PLLP 47 LakinChapman LLC 47 unduly prejudiced 47 Matoesian 47 Tim Pestotnik 47 Oesting 47 ResQNet 47 Fifth Circuit 47 toxic tort 47 Gerald Meunier 47 reasonable factfinder 47 Caruolo Act 47 prejudgment remedy 46 Lloyd Kirschbaum 46 seeks unspecified damages 46 promissory estoppel claim 46 joinder 46 daughter Tonni Covel 46 alleging wrongful dismissal 46 Elizabeth Cabraser 46 procedurally improper 46 lawyer Cyrus Mehri 46 lawyer Steven Donziger 46 liberal justices dissented 46 SCERS 46 Richard Laminack 46 Jackwig 46 sue 46 Amended Complaint 46 pro se litigant 46 Molchatsky 46 Janice Magaoay 46 statutory aggravators 46 Rusty Hardin Victoria Osteen 46 litigators 46 Lindevaldsen 46 legally cognizable 46 Rooker Feldman 46 Compensatory damages 46 forum non conveniens 46 jury verdicts 46 Chittenden Superior Court 46 attorney Roxanne Conlin 46 PRPs 46 Carmen Durso 46 Rob Fusari filed 46 nonsignatory 46 summary adjudication 46 predicate acts 46 Petitioners 46 Sara Buske 46 SLUSA 46 judicial estoppel 46 EEOC 46 Labaton Sucharow 46 Tamkins 46 Scott Summy 46 Slave descendants 46 appellate 46 Anascape Ltd. 46 Delaware Chancery Court 46 Sheller PC 46 Jay Eisenhofer 46 Attorney Stan Chesley 46 contractual indemnification 46 Judge Rakoff 46 Judy Guice 46 Cristobal Bonifaz 46 Minot derailment 46 Qui Tam 46 justices dissented 46 Richard Boeken 46 Shannon Liss Riordan 46 accused infringer 46 Knoll Lowney 46 pecuniary damages 46 conclusory assertions 46 Judge Beckloff 46 Nichols Kaster 46 Millrood 46 Sanford Dumain 46 depositions 46 Killino 46 Mohica Cummings 46 Zwerling LLP 46 suing 46 appellate courts 46 Kasowitz 46 Lifland 46 Stanley Chesley 46 Joel Waltzer 46 Max Wistow 46 Yuke Chue Lo 46 Zainey 46 Lancy Woo 46 & Grossmann LLP 46 Mayola Williams 46 Scott Kamber 46 equitably tolled 46 Iser Kump & 46 David Rudovsky 46 Title VII 46 Judge Rosemary Ledet 46 systematically underpaid 46 Plaintiff alleges 46 Attorney Fred Woocher 46 CUTPA 46 Ron Perey 46 Taishan Gypsum Co. 46 Hrayr Turabian 46 collaterally estopped 46 fraudulent conveyance 45 lawyer Stan Chesley 45 Lawyers 45 Feesers 45 preliminary injunctive relief 45 Terry Collingsworth 45 Molski 45 unspecified damages 45 Mark Rodberg 45 postjudgment 45 d efendants 45 Richard Eymann 45 Napoli Bern Ripka 45 Pigford II 45 Griders 45 qui tam provisions 45 collateral estoppel 45 Egilman 45 admiralty jurisdiction 45 damages proximately caused 45 anticipatory breach 45 habeas corpus proceeding 45 Boies Schiller 45 Eva Rowe 45 equitable indemnity 45 Underwriter Defendants 45 mass torts 45 meritless 45 Judge Sabraw 45 Eglet 45 Katrina levee breaches 45 treble damages 45 Dole Bananas 45 filing frivolous lawsuits 45 lawyer KAD Camara 45 CJAC 45 Laurence Drivon 45 impliedly preempted 45 Izard Nobel 45 attorney Chet Pleban 45 Judge Carol Higbee 45 Gregory Lattimer 45 Village Roadshow Universal Pictures 45 postconviction counsel 45 amici briefs 45 attorney Ira Rothken 45 Refco creditors 45 Fred Furth 45 limine 45 Piuze 45 appelate court 45 similarly unavailing 45 unlawful detainer action 45 Allan Kanner 45 amicus curiae briefs 45 Judge Sprizzo 45 procedurally defaulted 45 issue preclusion 45 Bernstein Litowitz Berger 45 Kasowitz Benson 45 Knauf Plasterboard Tianjin 45 Bryan Vroon 45 negligent infliction 45 Mitchell Garabedian 45 Mark Werbner 45 Lynn Sarko 45 Riegel v. 45 Sprizzo 45 dissident Wang Xiaoning 45 privity 45 jurisdictional prerequisite 45 Pechman 45 Merck knowingly misrepresented 45 Papantonio 45 Civil Procedure section 45 EarthJustice 45 Appellate Division affirmed 45 Katskee 45 Theodore Boutrous 45 Plaintiffs assert 45 anti SLAPP 45 Berman DeValerio 45 Diane Milutinovich 45 movants 45 KamberEdelson 45 SLAPP suit 45 Craig Levien 45 Elouise Cobell member 45 rehearing en banc 45 Zoe Littlepage 45 Thomas Hungar 45 Seth Safier 45 Plaintiff asserts 45 Borings 45 Andrew Levander 45 Gita Deane 45 David Oesting 45 Clark Vellis 45 FINRA arbitrations 45 plaintiffs appellees 45 Plaintiffs Counsel 45 Patricia Millett 45 Chitwood Harley Harnes 45 Panish 45 Zhai Feitian space 45 midtrial 45 unconstitutionally discriminatory 45 Zwerling Schachter 45 contributorily negligent 45 Tycko & 45 Judge Preska 45 Jody Mock 45 unspecified compensatory damages 45 Tanford 45 recusal motion 45 Knauf Gips KG 45 arguable merit 45 Podhurst Orseck 45 Forgent patent 45 joint tortfeasors 45 Betty Dukes greeter 45 Judge Eduardo Robreno 45 Robert Eglet 45 causation 45 slave Dred Scott 45 Judge Owen Panner 45 Barbara Grutter 45 Judge Eldon Fallon 45 Sorgato 45 Tanick 45 Diazes 45 McCurn 44 Judge Scheindlin 44 Judge Samuel Sferrazza 44 Christopher Lebsock 44 Keepseagle 44 Perer 44 estop 44 Damrell 44 Appellate Division reversed 44 Lawsuits 44 Roy Englert 44 Even assuming arguendo 44 uncontroverted facts 44 lawsuit alleges 44 Schlichtmann 44 attorney Bruce Rogow 44 pleadings 44 Judge Julia Aurigemma 44 Marilyn Keepseagle 44 Judge Carl Barbier 44 & Waichman 44 Olson Boies 44 Attorney Alan Gura 44 Defenders GLAD 44 Samuel Buffone 44 floated Levitch 44 Alien Tort Statute 44 Superior Court Appellate Division 44 joint tortfeasor 44 Defendants Appellants 44 evidentiary rulings 44 ERISA fiduciaries 44 philanthropists Stanley Chais 44 Seger Thomschitz 44 declaratory injunctive 44 Gribow 44 Petitioners contend 44 indemnitee 44 pari delicto 44 Nicaraguan banana workers 44 Ozanne lawsuit 44 Sheila Birnbaum 44 vexatious litigant 44 adequately pled 44 grievant 44 Alan Statman 44 Judge Gladys Kessler 44 False Claims Act 44 Scrabulous creators 44 pro hac vice 44 Vianale & 44 counterclaim alleging 44 NYCHRL 44 Alvarez Machain 44 Marlin Riggs 44 AnimalFeeds 44 Shook Hardy 44 Hendelson 44 tortfeasor 44 Lead Plaintiffs 44 & Bendesky PC 44 Lago Agrio plaintiffs 44 evidentiary objections 44 Glennon Threatt 44 Knauf Gips 44 Musladin conviction 44 sovereign immunity doctrine 44 lawyer Theodore Boutrous 44 patent infringment 44 propria persona 44 Lead Counsel 44 reprehensibility 44 Eberhard complains 44 Timothy Pigford black 44 RIAA subpoenas 44 unconscionability 44 Wrongful death 44 Brockton Contributory Retirement System 44 LongFellows Youth Academy 44 Larry Drivon 44 Janet Abaray 44 Koskie Minsky 44 Claimants 44 conclusory allegation 44 Alan Gura 44 California Unfair Competition 44 promissory fraud 44 posttrial 44 Bruesewitzes 44 Hrvol 44 Drivon 44 Judge Norgle 44 Judge William Bertelsman 44 TOMAC 44 waives sovereign immunity 44 McKool Smith PC 44 seeking declaratory judgment 44 Flexner LLP 44 restitutionary 44 Joshua Rosenkranz 44 Sanford Wittels & 44 Proposed Settlement 44 Rottenstein Law Group 44 wrongful discharge 44 Ben Barnow 44 Engle progeny cases 44 DeGuelle 44 Golger 44 Lagueux 44 landowners Native Alaskans 44 Khulumani 44 La.Civ.Code art 44 dependably foiled 44 Phyllis Molchatsky 44 vexatious frivolous 44 remittitur 44 Christie Bren 44 posttrial motion 44 Eisenhofer 44 Zivotofskys 44 appeals court 44 Cotchett Pitre & 44 Moznik 44 Harrises 44 plausible inference 44 Claryca Mandan 44 WildEarth 44 sole proximate cause 44 Rafeedie 44 Naftalis 44 illegal exaction 44 classwide 44 Woocher 44 postconviction relief 44 Richard Preira 44 Third Amended Complaint 44 quasi judicial immunity 44 Irwin Zalkin 44 interveners 44 RSUI attorneys 44 granted intervenor status 44 Charles Rothfeld 44 Lee Oskar Levitin 44 vexatious litigator 44 UMG Recordings Inc. 44 Sallie Hillmon 44 Paul Luvera 44 underinsured motorist 44 Lynne Bernabei 44 Cobell v. 44 vacatur 44 defendant intervenors 44 FTCA 44 Shinoff 44 Ledroit Beckett 44 Winkelmans 44 Rigsbys 44 Alien Tort Claims 44 patent invalidity 44 radiologist Matthew Lotysch 44 appellants contend 44 affiants 44 intervenor 44 Charles Blixt 44 Heisler LLP 44 habeas petitioner 44 Travelers Indemnity Co. 44 homeowner Angela Iannelli 44 court prejudicially erred 44 Jere Beasley 44 OnlineNIC 44 procedurally barred 44 habeas proceeding 44 arbitrability 44 Anapol Schwartz 44 purported Nicaraguan banana 44 Kosnoff 44 Gische 44 KinderStart.com 44 9th Circuit 44 Bernstein Liebhard 44 permanent injunctive relief 44 Boeken 44 Lisanbys 44 Defendant asserts 44 interlocutory appeals 43 Wally Fayssoux 43 Haeyoung Yoon 43 Lungstrum 43 Nick Brustin 43 Siskinds LLP 43 HBSS 43 Hartford Casualty Insurance 43 Loggans 43 Permanent Injunction 43 revocatory 43 Anascape 43 AGs 43 Guirola 43 lawyer speculative confabulations 43 Ted Boutrous 43 Judge Dickran Tevrizian 43 4th DCA 43 filing amicus briefs 43 Terence Kindlon 43 facially neutral 43 Vioxx prescriptions 43 Chancery Court 43 fraudulent joinder 43 mediation Kozinksi wrote 43 lawyer Dennis Vacco 43 & Eisenhofer 43 Justice Perell 43 Summary Judgment 43 SkyTel violated 43 tort reformers 43 attorney Wil Florin 43 Aguinda 43 Gammerman 43 Laura Knoppe 43 habeas petitioners 43 Carlos Murguia 43 Pregerson 43 argument unpersuasive 43 InNova 43 Douglas Honnold 43 Dmitri Iglitzin 43 Act FTCA 43 Mithoff 43 facially insufficient 43 Randy Mastro lawyer 43 Pratter 43 Noerr Pennington 43 Judge Philip Mangones 43 Stichting Brein 43 Counterclaim 43 Marschewski 43 Lago Agrio Ecuador 43 qui tam plaintiff 43 relator 43 constitutionally deficient 43 dischargeability 43 Carol Lynne Maner 43 Stan Chesley 43 indemnitor 43 AISLIC 43 counterclaims alleging 43 TMLC 43 Chaitman 43 Holly Ostrov Ronai 43 v. Dagher 43 Geller Rudman 43 Radical Bunny 43 Sanview Technology 43 Burt Neuborne 43 procedural unconscionability 43 Appellants contend 43 David Sigale 43 dispositive motion 43 nonlawyer 43 Officer Harold Nelthrope 43 constructively discharged 43 Stueve Siegel Hanson 43 lawyer Ches Crosbie 43 Cindy Naugle 43 attorney Marc Toberoff 43 Wettick 43 Defendant 43 Beau Blixseth 43 Vaccine Injury Compensation 43 construed liberally 43 von Saher 43 counsel performed deficiently 43 Cait O'Darling 43 Giatras 43 EAJA 43 Labaton Sucharow LLP 43 Ches Crosbie 43 noninfringement 43 Kmart Creditor Trust 43 Saltz Mongeluzzi Barrett 43 Judy Barrasso 43 Berger Singerman 43 facial plausibility 43 Thomas Van Orden 43 Antoninetti 43 wrongfully withheld 43 nonjusticiable 43 Lisa Kragnes 43 Rubin Sinins 43 mandamus 43 Goldfarb Branham 43 Jury Verdict 43 Ex parte Young 43 counterclaims 43 Marc Mezibov 43 WCJ erred 43 Robert Weinstine 43 Anadarko Exploration 43 arbitrators 43 GNAPs 43 Appellant asserts 43 Eleventh Amendment 43 Larry Bowoto 43 Altshuler Berzon 43 Donna Scroggin 43 Allvoice 43 lawyer Timothy Kosnoff 43 Thomas Cona 43 ICLU 43 Kasowitz Benson Torres 43 Plantiff 43 Donald Steier 43 Karl Cambronne 43 fraudulent misrepresentation 43 Quadrino Schwartz 43 Steven Salky 43 Muhammad Shabazz Farrakhan 43 Kenneth Nachbar 43 Neuborne 43 affirmative misrepresentation 43 Rosenbaums 43 Gene Schaerr 43 Loigman 43 USJF 43 Motley Rice 43 Michael Essmyer 43 Stobierski 43 Stratton Faxon 43 O'Quinn Laminack & 43 parol evidence 43 Grudberg 43 Derivative Action 43 prosecution laches 43 Jan Handzlik 43 Judge Joseph DiClerico 43 Settling Parties 43 Plaintiff Appellant 43 reargue 43 G. Bruguera 43 Grassmueck 43 Harold Lichten 43 Kherkher 43 Unsell 43 USAA Casualty Insurance 43 Injunctive relief 43 Talach 43 Luis Yanza 43 Axel Hagedorn 43 obstetricians surgeons 43 Drew Falkenstein 43 Reed Oslan 43 Blumrosen 43 Justice Eileen Bransten 43 George Keepseagle 43 interrogatory answers 43 McKiggan 43 NYCERS 43 wrongful dismissal lawsuit 43 patent reexamination 43 Stipulated Judgment 43 Adam Gutride 43 Defendants assert 43 Judge Arthur Spatt 43 Maura Wogan 43 Maureen Boesen 43 lodestar method 43 Vartkes Yeghiayan 43 Ninth Circuit affirmed 43 Judge Ellen Huvelle 43 equitably estopped 42 jurors 42 Brian Panish 42 Alan Perer 42 assuming arguendo 42 Noerr Pennington doctrine 42 commercial fishermen cannery 42 Hungarian Holocaust survivors 42 Ungaro Benages 42 http:/www.hbsslaw.com 42 Rhonda Gokey 42 permanent injunction enjoining 42 crane rigger William 42 Ann Oldfather 42 amici curiae 42 unlawful detainers 42 Meites Mulder Mollica 42 Plaintiff Complaint