Comment 041

next comment

Tags: * shorten time between submission and acceptance * against rolling review

"Reduce the time between submission and acceptance notifications. 8 weeks is too long for such a fast 
moving field. In the end, if the paper is not accepted and goes to a new cycle, it takes months for 
the original idea to be published (if lucky!) at which point the idea is probably not novel any more. 
Also, rolling reviews seem a waste of time for all involved. Reviewers are rarely satisfied byt subsequent 
iterations of a paper, especially if the reviewers change. I have the impression that it has not worked 
out as originally intended."