Comment 242

next comment

Tags: * link meta/reviews to conferences * survey confusing

"To me, the entire point of rolling review is lost if the reviews aren't directly tied to acceptance 
decisions. As a student, having a regular deadlines relieves a lot of stress, but that only works if 
the deadlines are real deadlines (like at CSCW) and not weird semi-deadlines where the reviews might 
mean something or might not and I might get the reviews in time for a conference or might not. The current 
ARR completely confuses me (I mean that its motivations confuse meSEMICOLON I've finally understood 
the labyrinthine mechanics), and so it was difficult to fill out this survey, which asked about very 
specific changes that to my mind are beside the point. Some of the questions were also worded in a confusing 
way, and so I answered ""no opinion"" for those questions."